Dual Boot Hell... Win10 and SSDs, is there an issue?

I've been through UEFI hell for days now, trying to get my nice, stable, reliable Hackintosh (Mojave) to dual-boot Windows 10. Config:...

I've been through UEFI hell for days now, trying to get my nice, stable, reliable Hackintosh (Mojave) to dual-boot Windows 10.

Config: Asus MAXIMUS XI HERO, i7 8700K, Sapphire RX580 Pulse 8GB, 2 big WD SATA data drives, 1 500GB SSD to boot Mojave, one 500GB SSD to boot Win10. The SSDs are (Mojave) the on-board m.2 nvme slot 1, and (Win10) an m.2 SSD in a PCIe adapter. UEFI boot with Clover. Made my Win10 installer with Rufus.

After a whole lot of trial and error and googling (because I'm not at all expert or even familiar with boot loaders and UEFI), I finally got a bootable Win10 and could run games on it and so on. It was up for over 24 hours without a hitch or a glitch, during which I spent an hour or two in a fairly demanding Windows game (Assassins Creed Origins) just to see how impressive the DirectX performance was -- I was wowed. But after shutting it down to switch back to Mojave, I couldn't even get to Clover... and so the nightmare began. Anyway, I'll spare you the long sad story. I tried a lot of things that didn't work before finding anything that did work. But I never trashed my MacOS boot disk and Mojave is still running just fine.

In the end I gave up on booting win10 from Clover. Couldn't figure it out. I added a special Clover entry to the boot list using UEFI shell so that Win10 couldn't stomp it, and set up a separate EFI partition for the Win10 SSD, configured with bcdboot. To switch OS I have to pause in BIOS and select Windows Boot Manager on the Seagate BarraCuda SSD, or Clover Boot Manager on the Samsung. It's not that big a hassle.

Please note that Mojave has been rock solid this whole time. No indication that there is any problem with memory, BIOS, etc.

Anyway, Win10's latest trick is this: I do a clean install, laboriously restore apps I DL'd and installed while it was running the first time, boot successfully... then try to start Steam, for example, and Boom, Page Fault in Non-Paged Area BSOD. That is sufficiently annoying, but it gets worse: after that BSOD the Win10 SSD is no longer bootable. The installer Repair options don't work. There's no recourse but (sigh) a whole new clean install, which takes about 2 hours including the file copy. And after that 2 hours of tedium, it might stay up for 10 minutes if I'm lucky.

I can't explain why Win10 was solid for its first 24+ hours, or why it's now borking after only a few minutes of use. I can't explain why it thinks its boot disk is toast and cannot be repaired, yet I can mount it from Mojave (using Tuxera NTFS) and the files look OK.

I ask this question here rather than on a WinDoze forum because I figure as soon as I mention Hackintoshes no one will talk to me in a WinDoze forum :-) also because lots of Hackintoshers have tried and succeeded to get their Hackie to dual-boot WinDoze so perhaps someone has been down this road before me.

Obviously I'm starting to wonder about hardware; so I'm running memtester right now, but with no expectation of finding a problem: Hackie is like I said, rock solid even when maxing out main mem with Parallels Win10 VM plus Steam games plus brew install this and that. I mean, I can't break it.

So, though I know Win10 is fragile compared to MacOS this seems extreme. I'm not an expert systems builder (it's a struggle each time for me to get my Hackintoshes to work) and this is my first use of internal SSDs so I don't know whether there are issues with Win10 and SSDs. Seems like this community is more knowledgeable (and courteous) than average so thought I would dare ask for some advice or pointers. I've wasted at least three days of precious "spare" time trying to get this dual-boot thing figured out, and right now I'm feeling like it might be more cost-effective to build a separate Win10 gaming box :-)

submitted by /u/Tazling
[link] [comments]

@Tonymacx64 - Latest Comments,51,about,6,amd,11,app,1,apple,4485,apps,10,asus,1,ati,8,audio,15,beta3,1,bios,3,boot,33,catalina,2,chimera,5,cmos,1,compatible,1,cpu,11,dev,3,donate,2,download,156,dsdt,19,error,1,fix,86,forum,148,game,1,gpu,43,guide,106,guides,3,hack,1,hackintosh,19367,hardware,14,hd,4,iatkos,614,icloud,3,ide,1,ideneb,1,imac,1,imessage,2,india,4,insanely,46,install,6,ipad,1,iphone,1,kakewalk,2,kernel,7,kexts,34,l,1,l1,119,l2,103,l2m,1,l3,11,l4,3,l5,2,laptop,3,leopard,2,linux,1,lion,181,mac,114,macbookpro,1,MacBreaker - Latest Comments,281,ml,280,ml2,1,ml3,2,mlm,3,motherboard,10,multibeast,7,multimedia,1,myhack,1,network,9,news,4617,niresh,30,nvidia,9,osxdaily,112,patch,1,requirements,1,s3,21,sata,1,sl,57,smbios,1,snowleopard,83,software,5,themes,2,tools,64,torrent,3,trick,1,uefi,1,unibeast,2,update,17,usb,2,users,1,v7,5,video,30,virtualmachine,3,vmware,3,wallpaper,4,windows8,4,
iATKOS Inside: Dual Boot Hell... Win10 and SSDs, is there an issue?
Dual Boot Hell... Win10 and SSDs, is there an issue?
iATKOS Inside
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copiar todo el código Seleccionar todo el código All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy